Interesting article. You earned my Sub.

I am not familiar with this book, so I will have to rely on your summary.

I am not sure that I like the concept of "instrument of expansion."

I think it combines together too many different concepts:

1) Economic growth

2) Extraction of the benefits of economic growth by elites or the state

3) Military conquest of other societies

I think that it is far more useful to keep those concepts separate rather than combining them together in one concept.

I think a far more useful concept is "Society Type" which I write about in my book series and my Substack column:



The concept of Society Type is based on how society acquires enough food to survive in its natural environment. You might find the concept of use.

Expand full comment

Interesting article, the tragic truth of the matter is that the state has decayed beyond all reason in all countries save one or two. Likely the 21st century will see a number of coups, revolutions and civil strife so that some civilisations will fall, and others will attempt to save themselves from modernity.

Those still in good health such as Vietnam will look to expand, others in decay such as Canada will collapse, and others still such as France will likely face civil strife and revolution until she is restored to good health as always seems to happen with France.

Some such as Japan will withdraw ever so slightly from the world until her demographics are fixed, others will collapse into a shadow of their previous selves still formidable but not as powerful (as might happen with Chine), and still others will probably survive after uniting with 'another nation' as in the case of the two Koreas. In my view, the dominant power of Asia will turn out to be Vietnam, Europe will see either France or Hungary dominate for a time (or a coalition between the two) and in Africa Kenya will sweep its way to power along with a Franco-Africain coalition.

In the Americas if America gets her act together, she'll probably dominate though go back to her reclusive ways of the 19th century. If not, she'll balkanise and we'll see what happens next.

But there'll be sunny days for some, and not so sunny days for others. Let us hope some measure of good health will return to some civilisations.

Expand full comment